Back to all energizers

Participatory Structure · Creative thinking

Wicked Question Pulse

Participants identify two opposing truths that must both be addressed, then turn them into a 'How is it that we... while simultaneously...?' question.

When to use it: Use once a real strategic tension has surfaced, typically mid-to-late workshop.

How to run it

Explain and demonstrate

Be clear that the source method is a roughly 30-minute Liberating Structure; our current 'Pulse' label is a shortened adaptation, not the original method. To run the full source structure, name a shared challenge and invite participants to individually list forces or realities that are true about it, including opportunities and difficulties. Ask them to circle two truths that appear opposed but both need attention. Display the template: 'How is it that we are ______ while simultaneously ______?' Each person drafts a Wicked Question from the two truths. Form groups of four to six to help sharpen the questions so they express a genuine tension rather than blame or an either/or choice. Return to plenary, hear several strong questions, and ask which ones have the most potential to move the work forward. If you retain a 8–10 minute 'Pulse' adaptation in this library, label it explicitly as an adaptation: 1 minute individual truths, 2 minutes create a question, 4 minutes pairs/quartets refine, 2 minutes share.

Show this clearly

What to demonstrate

Show one non-example ('Why can't management communicate?') and one true paradox using the exact sentence template.

Participant rules

Keep the activity clear

Both sides of the question should be desirable/necessary truths, not a complaint disguised as a question. Avoid blame.

When to stop

Finish with purpose

Full source: about 30 minutes. Proposed quick adaptation: 8–10 minutes, clearly labelled as adapted.

Accessibility and adaptation

Adapt it to the people in the room

Works with seated participation; avoid putting individuals on the spot.

Touch
No touch
Movement
Low
Noise
Quiet
Materials
Paper optional
Use judgment: Do not call this a pure energizer when the structure requires reflection; protect the full minimum time.

Embedded

Reflection

What?
What two truths are we trying to hold at the same time?
So what?
Why is treating this as an either/or problem limiting us?
Now what?
What experiment could help us make progress on both sides?

Original source / Further reading

Liberating Structures

Open source website

Need another option?

Return to the library and choose for the room you have.

Find another activity
Ethiopic-style illustrated guide for Wicked Question Pulse